Who Cares about Philosophy?by P. Brannock - 2008. As published on politac.orgObservations on the subject of philosophy, self reflection, and self inquiry.
The process of choice
Whether we like it or not, one's philosophy, or in the sad case of some, lack of philosophy, defines their life and who they are. This is inescapable. Life is an ongoing series of choices and consequences.
The intellectual process by which people make their choices may, perhaps, be one of the most important, while, for many, the most neglected aspects of their lives. We all go through the process of making choices on a regular basis. Not so many of us take the time to subject the process by which we make those choices to an introspective examination.
Socrates is reported to have observed, "The unexamined life is not worth living." It seems that Socrates had a passion for examining his own thought processes and those of others.
The social challenges of choice
Quite understandably, the process of our upbringing trains us to be actively interested in whether our choices will be approved by those whose opinions we care about. This matters to us. It matters a lot.
We seem to be less inclined to venture into the unfamiliar intellectual territory of considering whether the opinion of those we care about should be what it is.
Conforming to the social demands of a chosen social niche or clique, seems for many, to be the primary preoccupation in the decision making process. Unfortunately, questioning the core values and beliefs of the chosen clique is often a dangerous and risky proposition that may well result in being ostracized simply for asking the "wrong" questions, or worse.
Socrates was sentenced to death for asking the wrong questions and, thereby, corrupting the youth.
The limiting preoccupations of choice
Much of what we dedicate our discretionary time to prepares us to relate to others in social circles that give us a feeling of inclusion, acceptance, and respectability with a minimum of conflict.
For many the growing up process from childhood to adulthood is much like the path of a pin ball. Some are launched into a hostile and aggressive world and quickly learn to react to the repelling forces that define their comfort zones by elimination and avoidance of conflict.
For others, growing up is more like belonging to a theatre group where favored behavior is rewarded with approval, accolades, and prizes.
Many, if not most of us develop into slaves to the expectations of a world dominated by unseen social forces that compel our actions and choices. Fear, rejection, and the dominance of the narrow special interests of those who have managed to scratch and claw their way to the top of the social heap have more to do with the life choices of some than noble aspirations that often elude them.
Approval, acceptance, and the safe feeling of conforming to the requirements of the status quo dominate the motivation of others.
We love the feeling of independence and freedom, but all too quickly we find ourselves investing what little freedom and independence we have in the pursuit of the approval and acceptance or the avoidance of condemnation of a fickle world who's values are fluid manifestations of evolving culture, traditions, and political power.
It is for this reason that many people never lift their lives above the glass ceiling of their chosen social niche.
The impact and defining nature of choice
Each of us moves through life, from day to day, confronted with choices, the outcome of which will have an impact on our lives in varying degrees.
Some choices are small and relatively inconsequential. Some are huge. Some small and inconsequential choices seem difficult and challenging. Some choices that seem small and insignificant have enormous consequences that alter the course of our lives permanently.
Each choice requires some measure of thought as we process our options. We think. That is the process.
James Allen wrote, "The aphorism, 'As a man thinketh in his heart so is he' not only embraces the whole of man's being, but is so comprehensive as to reach out to every condition and circumstance of his life. A man is literally, what he thinks , his character being the complete sum of all his thoughts." James Allen, As a Man Thinketh
The values of choice
The process by which we make choices is a matter of individual discretion to the extent that we are left to choose freely. In making choices, some of us, if we are in the least bit rational, give consideration to what the reasonably anticipated impact of the choice will be to what matters to us. What matters to us, we refer to as our values. We value the opinions of our social niches. We value independence and freedom. We value our goals and objectives. Some of us value our ethics. For some, there is no meaningful distinction between their own ethics and the opinions that dominate their social niches, having adopted the ethics of the group without consideration for its validity. For these, conforming is more important than being right.
The integrated hiearchy of perceptions and values
Most of us have an evolving system of values that we manage in an evolving hierarchy of importance. The greater the importance placed on the value, the greater the weight of consideration it is given in making choices that might impact it.
Generally speaking, people's values begin with and remain connected to some measure of awareness of the realities of the world in which they live. Whether social expectations, or physical realities, our perception of these realities is inseparable from the system of values we maintain.
This system of discriminating awareness, however well, or poorly developed it might be, is an inescapable part of the dynamic of our lives. It is, at the end of the day, that which makes us or breaks us, whether we know it or not, whether we understand it or not, and whether we care or not.
This integrated connection between our perception of reality and our values is the philosophic system that either enslaves us or liberates us as we move through life making choices with an accumulation of consequences. It makes no difference whether we know this to be our philosophy or not and whether we care that is our philosophy or not. It impacts on our lives, just the same.
Who Cares about Philosophy? Anyone who cares about their life and its course should care about their philosophy. Anyone who hopes to change the course of their life should care about their philosophy. Anyone who is involved in or considering becoming involved in a serious relationship should care about philosophy. We cannot ignore it and we cannot escape it. It is who we are. It is what we are. It is, after all, by thought, that we are.
Where will your choices take you?
What is your goal? What do you seek? What do you hope for? What drives your choices in life? What kind of life have your choices left you with? By thought, or lack of thought, you are a product of your world view and the process by which you have integrated your life into that view by choice. You are a product of your own life philosophy.
One holiday season a young woman proudly shared her acceptance to the college of her choice with family members gathered for the traditional meal.
An elderly uncle, who had enjoyed considerable financial success and respect in the family for that reason asked what her major was. She hadn't decided and thought she would take general courses until she narrowed down her interests.
"What did you major in?", she asked. "Philosophy", replied her uncle. She expressed her surprise, having understood his success to have been accumulated in real estate and financial pursuits.
"Philosophy?", she asked. "I would have never guessed. Is there money in philosophy?" The savy old man leaned back in his chair and snipped the end off a cigar he was preparing to take outside after the meal. He smiled at the girl. "If you have the right one", he replied.
[Much appreciation goes to the anonimous contributor who pointed out that the anecdote above was "stolen" from a scene in "Max Dugan Returns" (Screen Play by Neil Simon) The contributor pointed out that the cigar smoking Jason Robards delivers that exact line to Matthew Broderick. This author had not seen that movie and heard the anecdote from a co-worker many years ago. This author understood him to be telling a story from his own family experiences. We appreciate the anonimous input. For whoever gets credit for the anecdote... it is an insightful one, and it makes a good point. We certainly want to be supportive of original credit going to whoever deserves it. Thank you!]
Each of us seeks success on a variety of levels. We want to be happy. We want to be safe and secure. We want to enjoy life and what it has to offer, and so we should.
We hope the world in which we live will afford us a fair opportunity in pursuing such goals, and so it should.
We hope to choose a life partner who will contribute to such goals, and so they should.
Now, with that in mind… one of the greatest epiphanies of understanding that occurs in the transition between being a child and maturing into adulthood… one that actually never dawns on some unfortunate souls, is that every choice is not equal in its likelihood of contributing to the success we seek.
Time, energy, and all of life's resources are limited. We must, therefore, choose wisely. We must, therefore, be discriminating with our choices. We must be discriminating with the investment of our time, energy, and all of life's resources.
The very process of discrimination that we employ, to be successful, must not only be consistent with our goals, it must also be consistent with reality to be sustainable.
If our belief system does not afford us this consistency, our course will not be sustainable and we will find ourselves and our own choices to be the greatest obstacles to our success and happiness in life.
In order to be successful, we must choose wisely. In order to choose wisely, we must discriminate appropriately. What we don't choose, is as important as what we do choose. The wasting of time, energy, and life's resources is as impactful on our lives as the appropriate investment of those resources.
Wise discrimination that leads to success is the point of the pursuit of philosophy.
Who needs Philosophy?
Who Cares about Philosophy?
Anyone who wishes to direct their life in a proactive and meaningful way should care about philosophy.
Anyone who desires success and happiness and who believes that their chances for it are improved by making wise choices should care about philosophy.
Ayn Rand, famous for her philosophy of "Objectivism" wrote,
"A philosophic system is an integrated view of existence. As a human being, you have no choice about the fact that you need a philosophy. Your only choice is whether you define your philosophy by a conscious, rational, disciplined process of thought and scrupulously logical deliberation -- or let your subconscious accumulate a junk heap of unwarranted conclusions, false generalizations, undefined contradictions, undigested slogans, unidentified wishes, doubts and fears, thrown together by chance, but integrated by your subconscious into a kind of mongrel philosophy and fused into a single, solid weight: self-doubt, like a ball and chain in the place where your mind's wings should have grown."
Ayn Rand, Philosophy: Who Needs It
You should care about philosophy. Our philosophy defines us. Your philosophy defines you.
What about Religion?
See also: Hostile Feelings without Reason
See also: Other Interview Responses and Articles